Embryo monitoring (e. g. time lapse, EmbryoScope). Can it boost IVF success rates?

Does embryo monitoring boost IVF success? What is it and how it works?

What is embryo monitoring and what role does it play during IVF treatment? What are advantages of using real-time monitoring? Does it affect embryo quality or their selection?

All you have to know is presented by experts in 3on1 #IVFANSWERS:

  • Małgorzata Wójt – Embryologist at Salve Medica
  • Dr Andrii SozonykHead Doctor, obstetrician-gynaecologist Parens IVF Center
  • Dr Ruth Sánchez – Gynecologist at PreGen, The Reproduction Unit at Clinica Vistahermosa

Małgorzata Wójt, Salve Medica, Poland

Answer from embryologist Wójt

It’s a very difficult question. We have different types of time-lapse system: EmbryoScope, Esco system, Primo Vision and few others. They are all based on the method of pictures that are taken every few minutes without disturbing the conditions in which embryos are kept. Time-lapse is a very helpful tool in the hands of embryologists. Before the era of time-lapse system, we had only the possibility of morphological assessment. For example, the assessment of cleavage stage is based on two main criteria: the number of cells and their morphology. The blastocyst scoring is also based on two different criteria: the expansion state of blastocyst and the consistency of the inner cell mass and trophectoderm cells. Time-lapse gives us more information. Morphokinetics, as seen with time-lapse, can enhance the power of embryo selection because it allows for morphology to be assessed more accurately.
Time-lapse embryo monitoring allows continuous and – what’s very important – non-invasive embryo observation, without the need to remove the embryo from the incubator and the optimal culture conditions. The extra information about the cleavage pattern, morphological changes and embryo development dynamics could help us to identify the embryo with the higher potential. This assessment is very closely related to the optimal time of the individual embryonic division.
In my opinion, time-lapse is particularly important in two situations. Firstly, it’s when we perform the transfer on the second or the third day. At this stage of the embryo development, morphokinetics is very important. Embryos that are observed up to the blastocyst stage, undergo a kind of natural selection. Some of them, especially the ones with big defects, stop developing. Secondly, it’s the situation when we have more embryos than we can transfer. Two blastocysts, looking the same, do not always have the same potential. When we compare two equally looking blastocysts, we can sometimes see small and sometimes large gaps in the embryo development.
Unfortunately, sometimes things that seem obvious and beneficial to us, have no confirmation in clinical trials. Basing on the Cochrane Library, there are several clinical trials that say there is no clear evidence that time-lapse system increases pregnancy or live-birth rates. This means that, although time-lapse system is a very helpful device, it will not replace a good embryologist.


Dr Andrii Sozonyk, Parens IVF Center, Ukraine

Answer from Dr Sozonyk

The morphological method is the main indicator of how we evaluate embryo quality. Embryos are evaluated according to the following criteria: the number of blastomers, the quality of blastomers and the presence of fragmentation. However, this is old method of assessing the quality of embryos is not without drawbacks and it is subjective. The embryo is extremely variable in its development. Ugly duckling embryo quality on the second day can develop into a completely healthy and very pretty baby.
Currently, a new game changer – the EmbryoScope method – turned up for assessing the quality of embryos. Its principle is the following: every 10-20 minutes a snapshot of the embryo is made in 7 layers using a computer program. The pictures are superimposed one on top of other and a short video summary of each embryo is obtained. EmbryoScope is the household name of the device of the new generation. At its core, it’s an incubator that supports the conditions for the growth and development of cultured embryos. But there is a difference which makes the breakthrough in the reproductive biology. Using the lenses and the camera built into EmbryoScope, we can observe what change occurred in vitro with embryos from the moment of fertilisation and up to 5-6 days of the development. The camera takes pictures every few minutes. The images subsequently form a video in which we see how the embryo was at what time, in what sequence it grows and the fragmentation of the cells of the embryo progress.
Recently a large study was conducted and the result showed the analysis of those embryos that gave pregnancy and subsequent births. It turned out that all those embryos had similar crushing time intervals and other time-related morphological criteria. The so-called time lapse system showed that a new direction of morphology was born: morphokinetics. Using retrospective analysis, morphokinetics gives us answers to many questions that were previously a mystery.
This new technology can significantly increase the chances of pregnancy. On one hand, it is no longer necessary to get the embryo out of the incubator every day to study it under a microscope.
Now the embryo is not affected by physical factors, which it is most sensitive to at this stage of its development: temperature changes, light, vibrations or sound. On the other hand, we can select the best embryos with the highest potential of implantation and pregnancy. EmbryoScope allows us to see in real time what we previously could only guess about. Now we can replace assumptions, such as what really happened to the embryo from the moment we saw it for the last time, with full science confidence. It is also important that future parents can subsequently see how the life of their unborn child progressed from minute to minute.
The use of EmbryScope will allow even wider access to the selective transfer of one embryo. A selective transfer of one embryo allows us to reduce the number of multiple pregnancies without reducing the overall pregnancy rate. It significantly minimises the risk of complications for both the mother and her unborn child. Preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) makes it possible to select euploid embryos with a high probability of implantation. It allows to increase the effectiveness of IVF programs, reduce the frequency of early reproductive loses and increase the frequency of gestation.


Answer from Dr Sánchez

Time-lapse is a photographic technique used in cinematography to show different events that happen at very slow and imperceptible speed to the human eye. Several still images are captured at certain intervals of time, they are subsequently joined and assigned specific speed so that everything that has been captured moves quickly, achieving the visual effect – namely, time-lapse effect.
This technology has been incorporated into assisted reproduction laboratories as a system that allows constant observation of the development of embryos cultured in vitro. It does so by capturing images at certain intervals of time, without having to remove the embryos from their culture environment. In this way, the conditions remain stable, thus, favouring the embryo development. In addition, much more information is obtained from the embryos. That make us analyse them, compare them and select them better than in a conventional way, by being able to see in full camera all the in vitro development. So we can have a better selection and choose the best embryo to transfer.
In addition, the time lapse software allows to create reports and videos for each of the embryos. With it, we have a very useful tool to help us explain to patients why some of their embryos have been selected to be transferred and frozen, while others not.
This device allows to control the evaluation of embryos. It facilities the embryo development under stable conditions and without the influence of external human and environmental factors – as contrary to what happens in conventional incubators, which require continuous human manipulation to evaluate and select the best embryos. This computer technology allows greaterprecision than the human eye.
Time-lapse technology also allows to increase pregnancy rates by up to 20%, compared to traditional incubators used in assisted reproduction.


3on1 IVFanswers - three answers to one question

Three IVF experts answering the same question.

If you need help choosing an IVF Clinic Abroad
Spare 3 minutes of your time. You will save at least a few hours.

If you are looking for an egg donation clinic abroad, use the eggdonationfriends unique patients tool – Clinic Matching Test. Our consultants will analyse your needs and choose 3 overseas clinics which match your expectations. Our database of IVF centres includes only trusted fertility clinics which have experience in providing high quality services to international patients. The suggested IVF centres will contact you directly within 3 working days. Spare 3 minutes of your time – you will save at least a few hours! Our assistance is free of charge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *