IVF Success Rates – myths & figures revealed

What are IVF success rates

IVF success rates are usually calculated as a percentage of clinical pregnancies dividing the number of favorable results such as number clinical pregnancies by the number of procedures performed such as number of embryo transfers, according to the following formula:

number of pregnancies1 or number of live births2 / number of embryo transfers3

  1. Number of pregnancies – most often a clinical pregnancy in 6-8 weeks of pregnancy as it is rare for clinics to present data from the 12th week of pregnancy.
  2. Live birth means carrying a pregnancy to term and delivering a child.
  3. Embryo transfer means that the were at least one embryo regardless of its quality transferred.

Typically, such statistics show an average success rate between 30-50%. In the majority of clinics, statistics are presented for different age groups of the patient, in which case the differences in age-dependent success rates will be very large. Generally, the younger woman is, the likelihood of successful treatment is statistically higher. If you consider undergoing IVF Egg Donor program and you’re interested in IVF Donor Eggs success rates – please read this article.

At first glance, everything looks clear but if we analyze the presented data it will turn out that the statistics so presented do not include IVF cycles where the embryo transfer did not take place for various reasons. Further on, the article discusses the number of possible cycles.

Other ways to calculate IVF success rates:

  • clinical pregnancies / number of IVF cycles started
  • live births / number of IVF cycles started

IVF Success Rates as presented by clinics

From the point of view of the patient, IVF Success rates should mean the probability that your IVF treatment will be successful, that is, ending in a live birth, which is the aim of treatment. Most clinics in Europe are presenting IVF Success rates as a percentage of patients who become pregnant. Most often, the probability of getting pregnant is calculated in relation to the number of embryo transfers made and not the IVF cycles started – it is the so-called IVF Pregnancy Rates.

Not every Patient starting the IVF cycle will have embryos available – that’s why the statistics calculated on the started IVF cycle (including the cycle in which no embryos were given) will be much lower. On average, 10-35% of the started IVF cycles may end before the embryo transfer (source: CDC Report 2015).

Moreover, the presented data usually focus on statistical chances for pregnancy and not on the birth of a child. This is another element that will significantly reduce statistics – an average of 10% – after all, pregnancy can end in a miscarriage. As you can see, there are many factors to take into account, which can have a huge impact on the presented values.

From the point of view of the IVF clinic, IVF Success rates mean most often that the patient got pregnant, which is known as pregnancy rates because this is the objective of the IVF method. Is such an approach ethical from the point of view of the patient? Isn’t this way of presenting statistics intended to sell “false hope” to patients? What does this mean for the Patient from the medical and financial point of view?

IVF success rates vs IVF pregnancy rates

IVF success rates per embryo transfer

The graph below (Chart 1) makes it easy to see that the performance indicators change significantly with the age of the woman. For women younger than 35 years, the chance of getting pregnant (counted per embryo transfers) is around 54%, but already at the age of 45, it is only around 6%. If we take into account the live birth statistics, they will be around 46% for an age under 35 and around 2% for an age over 44. As you can see, the statistical differences between pregnancy and childbirth can be significant. The chart below presents a comparison of IVF success rates calculated as pregnancies per embryo transfers and live births.

IVF success rates - pregnancies per embryo transfer vs live births

Chart 1: IVF success (pregnancies) rates per embryo transfer vs live births

IVF success rates per started IVF cycle

The situation is much different when we consider treatment success rates per the cycle started (Chart 2) and not the transfer of embryos. In this case, the probability of pregnancy for a woman under 35 is approx. 38% with a live birth rate of 33% while the same for a woman over 44 years of age is approximately 3% and 1% respectively. It is easy to notice that these values are much lower than for IVF success rates calculated per embryo transfers. The chart below presents a comparison of IVF success rates – pregnancy for the IVF cycle started and the birth of a child.

IVF success rates per started IVF cycle vs live births

Chart 2: IVF success rates per started IVF cycle vs live births

Why IVF success rates per embryo transfer are higher than per started IVF cycle?

Statistically, there is a group of women of various ages who do not have oocytes collected in an in vitro programs and another group in whom, despite the collection of oocytes, transfer of embryos does not take place. These groups are usually not included in the statistics presented by IVF Clinics. Below we present a comparison of IVF success rates – pregnancies – (getting pregnant) per embryo transfer and per started IVF cycle, which exactly illustrates the difference in the success rate of treatment (Chart 3). As you can see in the graph below – IVF success rates calculated per started IVF cycle are much lower than those calculated per embryo transfer.

IVF success rates - pregnancies per embryo transfer vs started IVF cycle

Chart 3: IVF success rates – pregnancies per embryo transfer vs started IVF cycle

IVF success rates vs IVF cycle cancellation

As you can see the differences in success rates per woman age are huge. If we look at the figure calculated per IVF cycle and not per transfer (Chart 3 above), the differences in IVF success rates are really high. Isn’t it true that they deviate significantly from the information that can be found on the websites of IVF Clinics?

On average, the percentage of IVF programs in which embryo transfer does not occur for various reasons, is around 10-30% depending on the age of the woman. When calculating the IVF success rates based on embryo transfers, IVF programs that ended earlier and thus before the embryo transfer, are not included in these statistics. In that case, are they highly overstated?

Let’s see what numbers we’re talking about at specific age intervals of the patient. In the chart below, we present what percentage of IVF programs end for the following reasons (Chart 4):

  • due to the lack of embryos to be transferred (orange line) – considering the following two reasons,
    • before the oocytes are collected (blue line)
    • after collecting oocytes but before embryo transfer (red line)
IVF cycle cancellations before retrieval vs after retrieval

Chart 4: IVF cycle cancellations before retrieval vs after retrieval vs before embryo transfer

Of course, these are average IVF statistics for all patients with various diagnosed causes of infertility. For the above data, the causes of infertility are broken down as follows: Tubal factor – 13%, Ovulatory dysfunction – 15%, Diminished ovarian reserve – 31%, Endometriosis – 8%, Uterine factor – 6%, Male factor – 33%, Other factors – 17, Unknown factor – 13%.

The analysis was prepared based on CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) data from 2015 and involved over 90,000 IVF cycles, broken down by the age of women in the USA. 69% IVF cycles were performed using ICSI technique.

Source: CDC – 2015 Assisted Reproductive Technology, Fertility Clinic Success Rates Report

IVF Success Rates - Reality vs False Hope

IVF Success Rates – Reality vs False Hope, IVF wirh own eggs, woman aged 35-40.

IVF Success rates – what should you consider

In particular, you should know how the statistics were calculated. IVF Success rates with your own oocytes should be presented per woman’s age. Usually the age is divided into the following ranges: <35, 35-37, 38-40, 41-42, 43-44 and over 44 years. Why is it so important? The woman’s age has a decisive impact on IVF Success rates. Age and success rate are diametrically opposed. The age of a woman is much less important in the case of IVF program success using donor’s eggs – you can read about it here. Another element is the cause of the patient’s infertility: depending on the reason, the success rate can change significantly.

IVF success rates – the false hope?

The most difficult part of the IVF program is the process of stimulating and fertilizing oocytes and embryo development. So why do clinics usually skip this part in the treatment success rate statistics? In the pursuit of high values of treatment success rates presented on websites, clinics try to show the highest possible values. Imagine that we have 3 clinics and each of them shows statistics in a different way; the patient will usually choose the clinic that shows the highest value of treatment success rate while rarely inquiring what the values are really about.

Is it possible to estimate the costs of treatment based on IVF Success Rates?

It is very difficult, especially if the Patients base their calculations on statistics that clinics present most often, which is pregnancy per embryo transfers. It will be a little easier when we base the calculations on the live birth statistics. It will be even easier when the statistics are calculated with live births but taking into account the started IVF cycles for a specific age group. However, the ideal solution is to calculate costs based on the cumulative success rate of treatment, therefore the percentage of patients who were successful in, for example, 2-3 consecutive IVF cycles.

We have written a separate article about the cumulative success rates, which you will find here. However, it is very difficult to estimate the total cost of treatment. Even knowing the cumulative value of success for the 3 cycles of IVF which is, e.g., 82%, too much depends on the individual situation of the patient to develop such a calculation. What does 82% mean in this case? It means that for 100 patients, 82 will give birth to a live child. The question is whether you will really find yourself in this group.

Unfortunately, nobody knows the answer to this question today. It is not uncommon to find patients in clinics who attempt IVF 5, 6 or even 8 times but on the other hand, there are many patients who successfully finish the treatment on their first attempt.

Personalized IVF statistics based on individual parameters – IVF calculators

The best solution would be to check the expected treatment success rate in an individual way taking into account your age, the cause of infertility and other important parameters. Clinics do not offer such options but on-line IVF calculators are available, which can take into account such parameters. We checked how these calculators work and compared them with the article “IVF calculators – comprehensive comparison”. They seem to be a good solution for people who want to check the expected success rate of treatment with an independent source. The approach seems to make sense because they are the only places that can at least partially take into account your individual medical situation.

What influences the IVF success rates using patients’ own oocytes?

Many factors influence the success rate of an in vitro program using patient’s own oocytes. Those are, for example, the age of the woman, the individual medical situation and the history of treatment of genetic factors and others. It should be remembered that the quality of oocytes decreases with the age of the woman: the older the patient, the poorer the quality of her oocytes. This is related to many factors but the most important is the so-called aneuploidies in oocytes that can cause genetic disorders.

Below you’ll find the factors that have the biggest impact on the IVF success rate:

  • Infertility causes and woman’s age
  • The quality of partner’s sperm (unless the sperm comes from a donor bank)
  • Quality and number of oocytes
  • Fertilization process and applied additional procedures used in an in vitro laboratory, e.g. ICSI, AH (assisted hatching) blastocyst culture- embryo development till 5th day, PGS
  • Quality of embryos
  • Patient preparation for embryo transfer – the right implantation window

What does the IVF treatment process look like?

IVF process consists of several stages, each of them is of great importance for the success of the treatment program. The following information applies to the IVF program with Patient’s own oocytes.

  1. Qualification, preparation for the IVF Program, beginning of taking contraceptive drugs. Qualification, hormonal and genetic tests, partner sperm analysis. The patient should have indications to start this type of therapy.
  2. Beginning of hormonal stimulation. Deduction of the stimulation plan to retrieve the appropriate number of oocytes. Usually, the stimulation can last from 7 to 9 days.
  3. Collection of oocytes. Most often about 2-3 days after the end of the stimulation process. The collection is performed under general anesthesia (unless the patient has contraindications to anesthesia).
  4. Evaluation of oocyte quality and eggs fertilization with the sperm of a partner or donor. The use of procedures that increase the effectiveness of therapy in an in vitro laboratory: ICSI, AH, blastocyst culture and other.
  5. Embryos development up to 3 or 5 days. Cultivation and quality control of embryos for up to 3 days or to the blastocyst stage – 5 days.
  6. Preparing the patient for embryo transfer.
  7. Embryo transfer on the 3rd or 5th day.
  8. Care of the patient after the transfer.

IVF success rates – where to look for confirmed data?

Most countries have organizations that monitor the clinics in terms of quality and success rate of IVF treatment. Below you will find a list of recommended organizations that publish statistics based on a very large number of conducted IVF cycles.

  • ESHRE (European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology)
    The organization brings together European clinics and conducts monitoring for IVF success rates
  • SART (Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology)
    An American organization that provides very accurate IVF statistics in the US. More than 80% of US clinics report to SART.
  • CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)
    The agency operates under the Ministry of Health of the USA. It publishes statistics based on SART data and data obtained directly from IVF Clinics in the USA.
  • IVF calculators – online tools that allow you to calculate IVF success rate taking into account the individual medical situation of patients – check here.

Resources:

Cumulative live birth rates after one ART cycle including all subsequent frozen-thaw cycles in 1050 women: secondary outcome of an RCT comparing GnRH-antagonist and GnRH-agonist protocols, https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dew358

Predicting Live Birth, Preterm Delivery, and Low Birth Weight in Infants Born from In Vitro Fertilisation: A Prospective Study of 144,018 Treatment Cycles, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1000386

SART – Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, https://www.sart.org/

CDC – Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, https://www.cdc.gov/art/reports/2015/fertility-clinic.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *